It's Been Said Disclosure Could Destroy Religion — But Would It Really?

Mountain & Main Journal
Written By CAL TEBBS

For sixty-six years, the conventional wisdom has been that the discovery of extraterrestrial life would shake the world's religions to their foundations. The world's religions, it turns out, mostly disagree.

In 1960, NASA funded a now-famous report from the Brookings Institution on the implications of peaceful space activities. Buried in its pages was a warning that has shaped the conversation ever since. The discovery of intelligent life beyond Earth, the report suggested, would be "electrifying" for the world's religions — and, for some of them, potentially "especially damaging."

Sixty-three years later, retired Air Force intelligence officer David Grusch brought the idea roaring back into public life. In his 2023 disclosures, Grusch expressed the hope that revelation of non-human intelligence would deliver an "ontological shock" — a jolt that would force humanity to reconsider its place in the cosmos. The phrase has been repeated in nearly every major article on the subject since.

The question is no longer purely hypothetical. Beginning in May 2026, the federal government started releasing its own UAP files to the public, with successive batches following through the early summer. What has actually been released so far is a catalog of unresolved sightings — the Pentagon has been careful to say it cannot make a definitive determination about most of them — not a confirmation of non-human intelligence. But the conversation has clearly moved from the fringe to the front page. Which makes it a good moment to ask a question almost no one making the "shock" argument has bothered to ask.

Namely: what do the world's religions actually teach?

When you ask, a different picture emerges — one in which the major faiths have been thinking about this for centuries, sometimes for two thousand years, and in which their theological frameworks would be challenged by disclosure but, in nearly every case, not destroyed.

Here is where the major traditions, in order of size, actually stand.

Christianity (~2.4 billion)

Christianity is the largest religious tradition on Earth and the most internally varied on the question of life beyond it.

Catholic. The Vatican Observatory, founded in 1891, is one of the oldest astronomical research institutions in the world. In 2008, its then-director Father José Gabriel Funes argued that intelligent extraterrestrial life would not contradict Catholic faith, because limits cannot be placed on God's creative freedom. The following year, the Observatory hosted a five-day astrobiology conference. Brother Guy Consolmagno, the Jesuit astronomer who directed the Observatory from 2015 to 2025, went further: in a 2005 book published by the Catholic Truth Society, Intelligent Life in the Universe?, and across years of interviews, he said it is only a matter of time before extraterrestrial life is discovered, and that the Catholic intellectual tradition would have no theological problem with it. The harder questions — original sin across worlds, the meaning of incarnation if other intelligent beings exist — have been worked on by Catholic theologians since Nicholas of Cusa in the fifteenth century. The Observatory's current director, Father Richard D'Souza, put it simply in 2025: extraterrestrials, if they exist, "would be children of God." Open questions, but not new ones — and ones the Church is plainly comfortable holding in the open. Pope Leo XIV visited the Observatory himself in the summer of 2025.

Protestant and Evangelical. The picture is divided. By the nineteenth century, Protestant theologians like Thomas Chalmers were openly suggesting Christ's redemption might extend to other worlds. Billy Graham told interviewers he believed intelligent beings existed in distant space who worshiped God. But Pew Research Center polling shows white evangelical Protestants are markedly less likely than other Christians to believe in extraterrestrial life — only about 40 percent say intelligent life probably exists elsewhere, against roughly two-thirds of Catholics and other Protestants. The most theologically conservative Protestants tend toward the view that scripture's silence on the subject is itself the answer. This is the corner of the Christian world where the Brookings concern lands hardest: a theology built on a strictly literal reading of Genesis would face real friction with disclosure.

Latter-day Saint. No Christian tradition has a more developed framework for inhabited worlds. The Book of Moses, part of the Pearl of Great Price, describes God creating "worlds without number" (Moses 1:33). Doctrine and Covenants 76:24 teaches that the inhabitants of those worlds "are begotten sons and daughters unto God." Joseph Fielding Smith, the church's tenth president, wrote that members have "brothers and sisters on other earths." Spencer W. Kimball, who would become the twelfth president, was direct in a 1962 address: "Are planets out in space inhabited by intelligent creatures? Without doubt." And the framework speaks directly to the supposed conflict at the heart of the "shock" thesis. President Russell M. Nelson, the current prophet, has taught that "all truth is part of the gospel of Jesus Christ," and that whether truth arrives "from a scientific laboratory or by revelation from the Lord, it is compatible." No church president has issued an official prophetic declaration on extraterrestrials, but disclosure would not contradict the framework. It would confirm it.

A genuine dissent. Not every Christian reads the phenomenon as extraterrestrial at all. A strand of popular Christian thought treats UAP as spiritual rather than physical — angels, or fallen ones. Vice President JD Vance, a Catholic, voiced a version of this in a 2026 interview, suggesting the easiest explanation is spiritual warfare. The late Catholic theologian Paul Thigpen explored the same possibility in a 2022 book and ultimately judged it an unlikely explanation for all UAP. It is the sharpest dissent inside Christianity — and worth naming honestly — but it is a dispute about what the phenomenon is, not a claim that the faith would collapse if it turned out to be life from another world.

Islam (~1.9 billion)

Quran 42:29 speaks of the creation of the heavens and the earth, and "all living beings He dispersed throughout both." The Arabic word dabbah — generally understood to mean corporeal, sentient creatures — has been the subject of centuries of scholarly commentary. Quran 65:12 describes seven heavens "and of the earth the like thereof," which Ibn Abbas, a companion of the Prophet, interpreted as describing multiple inhabited earths, each with their own prophets. The 2024 academic volume Islamic Theology and Extraterrestrial Life, edited by Shoaib Ahmed Malik and Jörg Matthias Determann, concludes that no Islamic teaching forbids belief in extraterrestrial life, and that several scriptural passages strongly suggest its possibility.

Hinduism (~1.2 billion)

The Vedic scriptures describe a universe populated with countless categories of beings across countless realms. Religious scholar David Weintraub has observed that Hindus would likely greet the discovery of extraterrestrials with little more than curiosity about where the new beings fit within the existing cosmic hierarchy. The framework already accommodates the answer.

Buddhism (~500 million)

Buddhist cosmology may be the most extravagantly populated of any major faith. The Anguttara Nikaya, one of the oldest collections of the Buddha's discourses, describes a universe of thousands of suns and thousands of inhabited worlds. The Dalai Lama, asked about extraterrestrial visitors, has said that should they arrive, they would simply be other sentient beings, treated with the respect owed to any being capable of suffering and awakening. The theological adjustment required by disclosure may be effectively zero.

Judaism (~15 million)

Rabbi Chasdai Crescas addressed the question of multiple worlds in fourteenth-century Spain. The eighteenth-century kabbalist Rabbi Pinchas Eliyahu Horowitz argued in Sefer HaBris that the universe likely contained intelligent life beyond Earth. In the twentieth century, Rabbi Aryeh Kaplan — both a rabbi and a trained physicist — drew on these earlier authorities to suggest intelligent life could indeed exist elsewhere. The traditional Jewish view, broadly, is that life elsewhere expands rather than contradicts the picture of God's creation.

What This Adds Up To

The picture across the traditions is a spectrum, not a single verdict. Buddhism and Hinduism would barely flinch. Judaism, the Catholic Church, the Latter-day Saint tradition, and most of Islam have frameworks ready for the news, with theological work still to do — much of that work they have already begun. The corner where the Brookings concern lands hardest is fundamentalist and biblically literalist Protestantism, where strict scriptural readings would face real adjustment.

There is even survey data on the point. Theologian Ted Peters ran what he called an "ETI Religious Crisis Survey," directly testing whether contact with extraterrestrial intelligence would throw the faithful into crisis. Most religious respondents did not expect their own tradition to collapse. The more striking finding was who did expect a collapse: secular respondents, looking in from the outside, were often more confident that religion would shatter than religious people were about their own faith. The fragility, in other words, may live mostly in the imagination of the observer.

Some religious frameworks would be challenged. None of them would be destroyed. The framing of disclosure as a civilizational reset for faith owes more to a particular mid-twentieth-century imagination — one that saw religion as fragile and science as inevitable — than to a serious reading of what the religions themselves actually teach.

One note on framing, since the terms may yet shift. The leading alternative to the extraterrestrial reading is not religious but physical: Representative Anna Paulina Luna, who chairs the House task force on declassification, has said repeatedly that the witnesses Congress has interviewed describe the phenomena as interdimensional rather than extraterrestrial. But whether such beings arrive from another galaxy or step in from another dimension changes nothing about the question asked here — the theology is identical either way. If anything, several of these traditions, which already speak of beings operating outside ordinary space and time, would find the interdimensional version the easier fit, not the harder one.

Jimmy Carter, a lifelong Christian who once reported seeing a UFO himself, may have put the believer's posture best. There is nothing to fear, he said: if there is life out there, we are still all part of the same plan, and God's hands are big enough to hold us both.

A universe larger than we imagined need not imply a God any smaller than we believed.

OTHER ARTICLES YOU MAY LIKE:

➜ Brandon Fugal — Building Empires, Chasing Mysteries at Skinwalker Ranch
➜ Are We Alone? The View From Utah

Sources

The Brookings frame

  • Brookings Institution, Proposed Studies on the Implications of Peaceful Space Activities for Human Affairs, prepared for NASA, 1960 — source of the "electrifying" and "especially damaging" language.

  • David Grusch, exclusive interview, The Debrief (Ralph Blumenthal and Leslie Kean), June 2023; testimony before the U.S. House Oversight Committee, July 26, 2023.

  • U.S. Department of Defense, Presidential Unsealing and Reporting System for UAP Encounters (PURSUE), public file releases beginning May 8, 2026.

Catholic

Protestant and Evangelical

Latter-day Saint

  • Pearl of Great Price, Book of Moses 1:33; Doctrine and Covenants 76:24.

  • Joseph Fielding Smith, Doctrines of Salvation, vol. 1.

  • Spencer W. Kimball, General Conference address, April 1962.

  • President Russell M. Nelson, remarks at the dedication of the BYU Life Sciences Building, quoted in Ty Mansfield, "Are People of Faith Prepared for Alien Contact?"Deseret News, May 16, 2026.

Islam

  • The Qur'an 42:29 and 65:12; Ibn Abbas, classical commentary.

  • Shoaib Ahmed Malik and Jörg Matthias Determann, eds., Islamic Theology and Extraterrestrial Life: New Frontiers in Science and Religion (I.B. Tauris / Bloomsbury, 2024).

Hinduism

  • David A. Weintraub, Religions and Extraterrestrial Life: How Will We Deal With It? (Springer, 2014).

Buddhism

  • Aṅguttara Nikāya (Pali Canon); public remarks of the 14th Dalai Lama.‍ ‍

Judaism

  • Chasdai Crescas, Or Hashem (14th century); Pinchas Eliyahu Horowitz, Sefer HaBrit (18th century); Aryeh Kaplan, collected writings.

Survey data and closing

  • Ted Peters, "The Implications of the Discovery of Extra-Terrestrial Life for Religion," Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A (2011), and the associated ETI Religious Crisis Survey.

  • Jimmy Carter, quoted via Deseret News (May 16, 2026), citing NPR's Scott Simon.

  • Rep. Anna Paulina Luna, interview on The Joe Rogan Experience (August 2025), with subsequent remarks reported by NewsNation and Newsweek (March 2026).

CAL TEBBS
Next

The Front Arrives