Utah Sports Ink
Last week we asked whether BYU still had a path to the College Football Playoff after losing to Utah. Read that story here. After Saturday's results, the answer is yes, by one of two very different roads.
BYU took care of its own business Saturday, holding Baylor scoreless in the first half on the way to a 28-7 win in Provo. The Cougars are 8-2 overall and 5-2 in the Big 12. But two other results shaped BYU's path more than its own game did.
Late Saturday night, Texas Tech routed Oklahoma State 52-27 in Stillwater to improve to 9-1 and 6-1 in the league. In Tucson, No. 2 Utah survived No. 23 Arizona 40-39 on a 70-yard touchdown pass from Devon Dampier to Creed Whittemore with 2:35 left. The Utes are 10-0 and 7-0 in conference play.
Road No. 1: Win out and stay home
This is the road ESPN thinks BYU should want. In its latest playoff projection, ESPN argues the Cougars may be better off not playing in the Big 12 Championship Game on Dec. 4. If BYU wins at Kansas on Nov. 21 and beats Cincinnati at home on Nov. 28, it finishes 10-2 with a win over Notre Dame on its résumé, a win that may hold up as one of the best in college football this season. ESPN projects BYU as the No. 10 seed in that scenario, with a first-round playoff game at Miami.
The numbers back it up. ESPN's playoff predictor gives BYU a 98% chance of making the field if it wins out and does not play in the title game. The danger in the other road is a second loss to Utah. A three-loss runner-up is a very hard sell to the selection committee. BYU fans know that story: last season the Cougars lost to Texas Tech twice, the second time 34-7 in the Big 12 title game, and they were left out.
Road No. 2: A rematch with Utah in Arlington
This is the road BYU fans dream about, and it is the only way BYU can win the Big 12 and claim the automatic bid. Beating Utah on a neutral field would give the Cougars the conference title, a win over the No. 2 team in the country, and the Notre Dame win, together one of the strongest résumés in the playoff.
But BYU can't get there on its own. Here is the math: Texas Tech has two games left, at Baylor on Nov. 21 and against TCU on Thanksgiving night. If the Red Raiders win both, they finish 8-1 in the Big 12 and clinch a title-game spot. BYU's best possible finish is 7-2. Even if Utah lost both of its remaining games and fell to 7-2, the Utes would win a tie with BYU on head-to-head, after beating the Cougars on Nov. 7.
In short: BYU needs Texas Tech to lose.
If Texas Tech stumbles, BYU likely wins the tiebreaker
If Tech loses once, BYU wins out and Utah wins at least one more game, BYU and Texas Tech would tie at 7-2. The two didn't play this season, so the first tiebreaker, head-to-head, doesn't apply. The second one is record against common conference opponents, and that is where BYU has the edge.
By our count, the common opponents are Arizona, Arizona State, TCU, Baylor and Cincinnati. BYU's two losses came against Utah and UCF, teams Texas Tech didn't play. Tech, on the other hand, already lost at Cincinnati, and its next loss would have to come against Baylor or TCU, both teams BYU beat. A BYU team that wins out would be 5-0 against those common opponents. Texas Tech would be 3-2.
That makes BYU's Nov. 28 game against Cincinnati about more than a win. It's the game that would give BYU the common-opponent edge over Tech. (A three-way tie at 7-2 is possible only if Utah loses both of its remaining games, and that would bring in a more complicated tiebreaker.)
The injury question
Either road runs through LJ Martin. The reigning Big 12 Offensive Player of the Year ran for 49 yards on six carries against Baylor before coaches held him out of the second half as a precaution. Backup Sione Moa also left the game hurt. Without them, Baylor stacked the box and BYU's offense lost its balance. Watch the injury report before Kansas.
Time to heal is another argument for staying home. Martin missed about a month with an ankle injury earlier this season, and coaches said he still wasn't fully healthy after the Holy War. If BYU skips the Dec. 4 title game, its regular season ends Nov. 28, and playoff first-round games are Dec. 18 and 19. That's about three weeks off, compared with about two weeks for teams that play in Arlington. For a banged-up backfield, an extra week of rest could matter as much as a higher seed. It's also one less game for a key player to get hurt again.
What to watch
- Sat., Nov. 21: BYU at Kansas; Texas Tech at Baylor; Utah at TCU. A Baylor upset changes everything.
- Thu., Nov. 26: Texas Tech vs. TCU on Thanksgiving night.
- Fri., Nov. 27: Utah vs. West Virginia, 7 p.m., FOX.
- Sat., Nov. 28: BYU vs. Cincinnati, the tiebreaker game.
- Fri., Dec. 4: Big 12 Championship, AT&T Stadium, Arlington, Texas, on ABC.
What about Utah?
The Utes have the most to protect. Utah is all but certain to reach Arlington, and a Big 12 title would lock in a high seed and a first-round bye. ESPN says that even if Utah wins its last two games and then loses the title game, it should still make the top 12, but it could drop significantly in the seeding.
So who is the tougher opponent? BYU knows Utah well, and the Utes already beat the Cougars 28-20 on Nov. 7. Beating a rival twice in one season is hard, especially when that rival is playing for its playoff life: a BYU loss would almost certainly keep the Cougars out of the playoff, so they would come to Arlington with everything on the line. Texas Tech is the defending Big 12 champion and has one of the league's most explosive offenses, scoring 52 points at Oklahoma State. But the Red Raiders came into last weekend ranked 136th of 138 FBS teams in passing yards allowed, a weakness Dampier and the Utah passing game could attack.
So which would you choose?
For BYU, the safer road probably gets the Cougars into the playoff as an at-large team. The riskier road could make BYU the Big 12 champion, with a second shot at Utah and the higher seed that comes with it, or it could leave the Cougars home for the second straight year. Texas Tech's results will decide which road BYU takes, but fans on both sides can still weigh in:
BYU fans: If you could choose, would you want the rematch with Utah for the Big 12 championship?
Utah fans: Would you rather face BYU again in the Big 12 championship, or take on Texas Tech?
See where these games rank in our Top 10 Events this week →
Sources: ESPN playoff projection after Week 11 · Salt Lake Tribune · Deseret News · ESPN game recap · CBS Sports tiebreaker guide
AI tools assisted with research and drafting for this article.

